There probably is some stuff they took out of Half-Life, but the stuff you demonstrated ain't it. Besides, Elizabeth is done better than Alyx and you gotta admit that. Almost every single game has a persistent female character, for example Princess Peach in Mario. And adding a female character is not copying. They either had no dialogue, or very little dialogue, save from the few lines that they say when killing someone, e.g. You know, it was almost a thing back in the day that no characters talked that much. also they realized that alyx made the story even better so what did bioshock do? lets add elizabeth! lol! i not saying bioshock isnt good coz as i sed before i love the series but if you look closely you will see that bioshock has a lot of copied stuff

like bioshock 1 ryan dont talk at all, i wonder what game they took that from lol.

Originally posted by moysey89:i love both, bioshock 1,2 and 3 and all the half lifes, i find the half lifes are better as they are more uniqe! i found that if you look closly at the bioshock series alot of what they iplemented in to it was copied from half life.

Half life 1 vs 2